May 9, 2019

By Intrigue

Are you looking for help with marketing your insurance brokerage in Ontario? The task of marketing insurance products and services can be challenging and it’s important to understand what tactics and initiatives will work — and what won’t work.

At Intrigue, our team has in-depth experience marketing to homeowners and developing strategies for insurance brokers and insurance companies. We have firsthand knowledge of what strategies are able to effectively generate leads in the insurance industry.

Read our case study for more details:

The Client

The Ostic Group is a local insurance broker with offices in Guelph, Shelburne, Elora, and Fergus. They provide a variety of personal and commercial insurance services to homeowners and businesses in the Wellington County and Dufferin County regions.

At The Ostic Group, their brokers live and breathe their core values of integrity, respect, professionalism, personal responsibility, and humour every day. Their company has an established history of providing insurance excellence to the local communities, dating back to 1880.

Marketing Services

Intrigue began helping The Ostic Group with their marketing in 2014. At the time, the main goals of their organization were to enhance their digital marketing and increase leads year-over-year.

Since working with our team, The Ostic Group has experienced consistent year-over-year growth in online leads and has also achieved a number of other important marketing objectives, including:

  • Measuring the effectiveness and return on investment (ROI) of all marketing channels
  • Increasing the number of referrals from current customers
  • Becoming the community leader for local insurance in the Guelph, Shelburne, Elora, and Fergus area

Proven Results in Lead Generation

In 2018, The Ostic Group received ~300 qualified leads from online initiatives.

When you break down the source of these leads, ~25% of them are contact form completions on their website and ~75% were from phone calls. For their phone calls, we were able to identify the following channels:

  • 21% Organic Traffic — These visitors found the phone number on the website, after searching on Google.
  • 17.5% Paid Traffic — These visitors found the phone number after clicking on a Google Ad or a Facebook Ad.
  • 61.5% Local Search Traffic — These visitors found the company’s Google My Business profile after finding it on Google Maps, in the Knowledge Panel, or in a local pack result.

Ostic Group Local Pack Results on Google

The Ostic Group’s digital marketing campaign includes a mix of different services, including:

  • Website Design
  • SEO Services
  • Blogging
  • Email Marketing
  • Google Ads
  • Facebook Ads
  • Local Video Advertising

Website Design & SEO Work

One of the largest pieces of work completed for The Ostic Group in 2018 was a design update of their website. Based on current marketing trends and user data, our team made improvements to enhance the site’s overall user experience (UX), conversion rate, and search engine rankings.

Our team approached the project with the following key objectives in mind:

  • Ensure it is easy for users to find what they are looking for on the site and navigate there with as few clicks as possible.
  • Make it simple for users to submit a quote request on individual service pages.
  • Help improve the search visibility of individual service pages with valuable content and enhanced technical architecture.

Ostic Group SEO Results Graph

These improvements to the site design and UX resulted in a 35.9% decrease in bounce rate across the site year-over-year.

The conversion rate optimization (CRO) was a major success for The Ostic Group and yielded an impressive 450% increase in conversions over the same period. In particular, conversions for niche services made large improvements, as a result of increased traffic to those specific pages.

Overall, the SEO work completed on the site resulted in a 34.7% increase in users and a 26.9% increase in sessions. It also greatly increased the profile of the company’s four Google My Business listings, resulting in a high number of direct phone calls.


Our content strategy for The Ostic Group aimed to address timeless (or ‘evergreen’) content, including questions or challenges about specific insurance situations or products. This strategy was designed to attract new visitors to their site, showcase the company’s authority in the industry, and increase traffic to their site year-over-year.

In 2018, blogging was responsible for over 5,500 sessions on The Ostic Group site — which was a 50% increase from their previous year.

  • ~40% of users found the blogs using Google searches.
  • ~25% of users arrived on the site because they were subscribed to The Ostic Group email newsletter.
  • An additional 25% came through Facebook.
  • The remaining 10% came from referral or direct traffic.

Ostic Group Blog Traffic Pie Chart

Although blogs are not designed to convert new visitors directly into leads, the blogs were responsible for 12 direct conversions and 12 assisted conversions in 2018. Many of the other leads were attributed to remarketing efforts, which were assisted by the blog strategy.

Email Marketing

The monthly email newsletter for The Ostic Group has been a consistent source of traffic and leads. Their newsletter brings between 100 to 250 visitors to their website on a monthly basis, depending on the season.

Their email marketing is outstanding for their industry. Their emails have an average open rate of between 25% and 30% (up to 10% higher than the industry average) and an average click-through-rate of 2.7%, which is also higher than the industry average.

Ostic Group Email Performance Chart

Google Ads

Google Ads have been a strong performer for The Ostic Group, despite the fact that the insurance industry is well-known for its high average Cost Per Click (CPC) on ads.

Our team was able to develop a successful strategy, targeting niche insurance products that were less competitive but still offered an opportunity for positive returns.

In 2018, Google Ads generated nearly 200 leads for The Ostic Group.

Over 50% of these leads came from contact form completions, with the remainder of the leads coming from phone calls from the website or ad extensions.

The website design updates also contributed to several improvements in user metrics for paid traffic, resulting in a 19% lower bounce rate and a 50% increase in session duration.

Ostic Group Google Ad Results

Facebook Ads

Our Facebook Ads strategy was designed to complement our other initiatives, by running ads that would remarket to users who had already visited a specific page on The Ostic Group website.

In addition to remarketing, our team also ran ad campaigns for specific insurance services. In total, the Facebook campaign was responsible for bringing 2,800 sessions to their website in 2018.

In particular, Facebook Ads generated ~50 leads for The Ostic Group. Over 75% of these leads came from contact form completions, with the remainder of the leads coming from phone calls.

Ostic Group Facebook Ad Results

Campaign Overview

So what does all of this mean for The Ostic Group?

The end result of our digital marketing efforts is that the average cost of an online lead or phone call for The Ostic Group is ~$200.

Given the lifetime value of a customer for an insurance broker like The Ostic Group, their team will only need to convert 1 out of every 10 leads into a lifetime customer to see returns on their digital marketing investment.

Want to find out how your insurance brokerage can achieve similar results with your marketing? Contact the team at Intrigue today.

Intrigue is a Canadian digital marketing company delivering solutions to help businesses get noticed and found. Guided by a commitment to empower leaders to strengthen communities, Intrigue offers website design and development, branding, online advertising, content marketing, graphic design, video production, SEO, and analytics. Take your marketing to the next level and Get Noticed. Get Found.®

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *